Member-only story
The Subtle Art of Shaping Minds: Differentiating Between Influence, Persuasion, and Manipulation
What sets these apart? Is intent the dividing line?
In a world filled with advertisements, political messaging, and daily interactions, how often do we stop to think about the subtle ways our minds are shaped? Whether it’s through influence, persuasion, or manipulation, we are constantly being guided toward certain thoughts and actions. But where do we draw the line between them?
My partner and I were watching a charming home remodeling show the other day when it was suddenly interrupted by a string of commercials. With election season approaching, several of the ads were political, but there were also a few for medications and cleaning products. As we watched, we started chatting about the emotional strategies each ad used — fear in the political ones, fear and shame in the medication ads, and a mix of exasperation and guilt for the cleaning products. That conversation got me thinking about the differences between influence, persuasion, and manipulation.
As I reflected on their characteristics, I began to wonder: Can we really separate these concepts by their ethical implications, or are they just points on the same spectrum of communication tactics?
